Track Order
Repair Services
Trade Ins
Cart
Locate Us
Refunds and Returns

Home
- Home
  Store Hours: Currently Closed
  Reopens Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM
  Video Games
  Game Accessories
  Graded Collectibles
  All Retro Toys
  Browse
  Repair Services
  
  My Account
  Track Order
  Contact Us
  About Us
Wishlist
Cart
Shop

My AccountLogin

Username or email address *

Password *

Remember Me

I'm new client. Create an account

Your cart is currently empty

Browse Categories

Game Accessories
Graded Collectibles
Retro Toys
Used Games
All Retro Toys
Repairs and Customization Portal
Hours & Location

Graded Collectibles

Home/Graded Collectibles

Show only products on sale

Product categories

Accessories
Board Games
Box Sets
Graded Collectibles
- PSA
Handhelds
Pokemon
Retro Rummage Customs
Retro Toys
Used Games

Price

$10 & Under
$10 - $20
$21 - $50
$51 - $150
$151 - $250
$250 & Over

Showing 1–50 of 75 results

Show only products on sale

Sort by

Default

Show

Show: 50
- 50
- 100
- 150
- 200

1990 Topps Simpsons "And Don’t Come Out Till You Sparkle, Boy!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$35.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "Bart! Get Back Here!!!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$33.12

1990 Topps Simpsons "BBAARRTTTT!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$39.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "Calm Down, Boy! It Was Just a Nightmare!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$63.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "Come Back Here, You Little Smartass!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$29.00

1990 Topps Simpsons "Fun Has a Name..." Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$32.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "I’m Bart Simpson, Who the Hell Are You?!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$41.40

1990 Topps Simpsons "I’m No Supervising Technician" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$37.10

1990 Topps Simpsons "No Rest Stops for the Next 16 Hours" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$31.68

1990 Topps Simpsons "Quiet! Genius at Work" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$36.84

1990 Topps Simpsons "Suck!" – PSA 9 Mint

$34.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "This Is the Life, Man!" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$33.36

1990 Topps Simpsons "Underachiever" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$28.70

1990 Topps Simpsons "Which One of You Ate My Last Donut?" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$38.99

1990 Topps Simpsons "Who Do You Think You Are, Thomas Edison?" Sticker – PSA 9 Mint

$41.70

Adventurer’s Discovery (Full Art) - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Lost Origin #TG23

$14.99

Arctibax - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - SV2P Japanese #076

$22.41

Baxcalibur - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - SV2P Japanese #077

$34.99

Brock's Geodude - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 1st Edition (2000 Gym Heroes)

$31.50

Brock’s Onix - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Gym Heroes #21 (1st Edition)

$54.99

Bulbasaur - PSA Graded MINT 9 - Japanese Basic Set (1996)

$28.99

Butterfree - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Jungle #33 (1st Edition)

$34.99

Caterpie - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Neo Discovery (2001)

$23.99

Charizard VSTAR - PSA Graded Gem Mint 10 - VSTAR Universe (2022)

$38.87

Dark Gyarados (Holo) - PSA Graded NM-MT 8 - Classic Collection (Team Rocket) - Celebrations #8

$26.99

Dhelmise VMAX - PSA Graded MINT 9 - Shining Fates (2021)

$22.41

Dodrio - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - SV2a Japanese #085

$34.99

Galarian Stunfisk V - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - 2020 Darkness Ablaze

$24.80

Greavard - PSA Graded Mint 9 - SV1V Japanese #087

$34.99

Grimer - PSA Graded MINT 9 - Fossil Set (1999)

$46.16

Hyperheiler (Trainer) - PSA Graded NM-MT 8 - 1st Edition German Base Set #82

$39.99

Incineroar GX - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Strength Expansion Pack (Japanese) - Hyper Rare #060

$27.99

Indeedee V - PSA Graded NM 7 - Shining Fates #039

$21.99

Indeedee V (Full Art) - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Shining Fates #SV114

$27.99

Kadabra - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 1996 Japanese Basic Set

$27.34

Keldeo - PSA Graded MINT 9 - Full Art (2023 Crown Zenith)

$40.79

Koga's Weezing - PSA Graded Mint 9 (1st Edition) - Gym Challenge (2000)

$71.69

Latios - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Shining Legends #41 (Holo)

$23.99

M Altaria EX - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 2016 Pokémon XY Fates Collide

$21.55

Machoke - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - Art Rare SV2a Japanese #177

$41.99

Mankey (Reverse Holo) - PSA Graded GEM MT 10 - SV2a Japanese #056

$27.98

Mega Pidgeot EX (Full Art) - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Evolutions #105

$42.99

Meowscarada EX - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Ultra Rare #231

$36.99

Mew - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Hidden Fates #32

$24.99

Mewtwo - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 2016 Pokémon XY Evolutions #51

$29.99

Nidoran♂ (Shadowless) - PSA Graded NM 7 - Base Set #55

$29.99

Parasect FA - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 2022 Lost Origin

$19.69

Penny - PSA Graded MINT 9 - 2023 Pokémon SVI EN #252

$23.34

Pikachu - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Crimson Invasion #30

$27.99

Pikachu - PSA Graded Mint 9 - Scarlet/Violet Pre-Order Promo #001

$49.99

1
2
Next page

Locate our store! Click Here

Store Hours: Currently Closed

Reopens Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM

168 Lake St N
Ste 3
Forest Lake MN 55025

763-888-GAME

Tb-icon-brand-facebook Envelope

About Us
Contact Us
Locate Us

Repair Center
Trade In

Check Order
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy

©2024-2025 The Retro Rummage Room. All Rights Reserved.
Shipping dimensions are for calculation purposes only; actual product sizes may vary. All sales subject to Terms of Use. The Retro Rummage Room is not affiliated with or endorsed by any third-party brand mentioned. All trademarks are property of their respective owners.

Menu
Browse Categories

Menu

Game Accessories
Graded Collectibles
Retro Toys
Used Games
All Retro Toys
Repairs and Customization Portal
Hours & Location

Game Accessories
Graded Collectibles
Retro Toys
Used Games
All Retro Toys
Repairs and Customization Portal
Hours & Location

Product has been added to your cart